We’re halfway through the 2025 eventing season, and it’s time to take stock. In this jam-packed episode, Nicole is joined by Sam, Spike, and Diarmuid for a full mid-season review. They look back on the standout five-star performances at Kentucky and Badminton, debate the dominance of Graffalo, Chipmunk, and London 52, and get stuck into some of the sport’s biggest questions—from judging controversies to phase influence to what makes a true five-star horse. Expect heated debate, expert insight, and plenty of name drops as the team maps out what’s happened so far—and what’s still to come.

🔍 Episode Breakdown

1. Graffalo vs. Chipmunk: The Rivalry Defining the Season A deep dive into the big wins at Kentucky and Badminton, comparing their HPRs, pressure performances, and championship potential. What separates these two legends—and where does London 52 fit in?

2. The Big Picture: Are We in a Golden Era? Sam makes the case for calling 2025 one of the greatest seasons of modern eventing, with generational talent peaking at once. Could we be witnessing a once-in-a-decade moment?

3. The Great Scoring Debate: Dressage, Cross Country & What Really Matters Does dressage have too much influence? Is the sport evolving in the wrong direction? Sam and Spike go head-to-head on phase weighting, training priorities, and whether we’re seeing the right kind of horses at the top.

4. European Championship Forecasts & Blenheim Speculation Who’s in the running for Team GB? The crew discusses likely selections, breakout performers like It's Cooley Time and Nickel 21, and how the second half of the season could shape team dynamics for the Europeans and Burghley.

5. American Power Plays: Reactions to the US Aachen Squad Nicole and Diarmuid unpack the US team announcement for Aachen, looking at the returning stars, the rising talent, and what it all suggests for Aachen World Championships in 2026. Bonus: why Jess Phoenix is one to watch.

👥 Featured Guests

Nicole Brown – Host, commentator, and the podcast’s midfield general.

Sam Watson – Elite eventer and numbers guru, calling for phase reform and deep appreciation for greatness.

Spike Milligan – Eventing vet and voice of reason (sometimes), sparring with Sam over training philosophies.

Diarmuid Byrne – Stat-backed sage with sharp takes on selections, trends, and what’s coming next.

📣 Call to Action

Think Graffalo’s the GOAT? Backing Chipmunk to finish strong? Loving the rise of Nickel or It's Cooley Time? We want to hear from you! Drop us your thoughts on Instagram and make sure you’re subscribed to the podcast so you don’t miss what’s next.